Why is Margin Requirement for Option Selling higher at Fyers compared to other Brokers ?

Margin Required at FYERS for - FINNIFTY 30 APRIL 21350 CE = 1,33,250 (~20% higher)

Margin Required at ZERODHA for - FINNIFTY 30 APRIL 21350 CE = 1,13,250

Margin Required at Dhan for - FINNIFTY 30 APRIL 21350 CE = 1,14,191

@communications_team, Tejas Khoday, Shruthi Shetty

Waiting for Reply over this !!!

Hey Pranav, we’re charging a margin of 110% as per the exchange guideline, and that’s the reason for the difference.

Shruthi Shetty** why exchange guidelines are different for **@communications_team ?? Do you mean other brokers are not following the guidelines?

@communications_team @shruthi_shetty awaiting reply over this.

@shruthi_shetty @communications_team - still waiting the response over this.

#margin

Arul, Tejas Khoday - Fyers requires 10% EXTRA Margin for option selling position as per @communications_team internal RMS. You guyz dont bother to let the customer know it ? Do you have mentioned it anywhere on the Fyers website ?

cc: @shruthi_shetty, @nsuyash11-m18

@shruthi_shetty, could you please share the link to the Exchange / SEBI guidelines you mentioned above ?
Fyers is charging more than 15%+ extra margin of what other brokers are charging, even after hedging margin benefit !

Margin Required :
Fyers : 36100
Zerodha : 31,025
Upstox** : 31,050**

CC : @communications_team @tushar_shinde

Hi @nsuyash11-m18, please check out the notice for a margin of 110%.

@shruthi_shetty - First get your calculations right ! Dont potray that you guyz are doing what exchange has told. You are charging extra on top of mandatory margin.

Your customer executive have already told me that your internal RMS charge extra 10% margin. The worst part is no customer knows this before opening the account. Everyone thinks that since margins are standardized it must be same across brokers, which is not the case with Fyers

cc: @nsuyash11-m18 @communications_team

When there are no answers. @communications_team team prefer silence.

Hi @nsuyash11-m18, please find the SEBI Circular in the following link. It is on page number 20, Annexure 5.

Hi Pranav, I understand your concern. But, we maintain a standard margin of 110% in times of volatility. Where as other brokers may not follow this, and their margins could change due to increased volatility.

@communications_team @pranavshinde @shruthi_shetty @nsuyash11-m18 @tushar_shinde
The margin at Fyers are way more than other brokers based on your RMS policies?? So for Option writers fyers does not provide better returns on investment. Example, For 10 lots of Nifty an option writer needs to pay approximately 2 lakhs more as margin if using Fyers which is a huge disadvantage. No other broker like Zerodha, Upstox, Dhan etc is having such high margin requirement as Fyers. High time that you change it.

@pranavshinde Fyers wont reply as they have nothing to answer :grinning_face:. Quit using their platform. Zerodha has currently updated their tradingview platform with trade from charts ( in Beta) which will be available shortly. For option sellers Zerodha is the preferred platform.