Some missing features in Fyers are really frustrating to conduct trades

I am new to Fyers and I find your trading platforms quite intuitive but some missing features makes them frustrating to trade with. For example,

  • Having no basket orders makes it so difficult to figure out the margin requirement on the go, for hedge position and strategies, and quickly place the orders.
  • From ‘Positions’ screen partial exit must be allowed. Now only closing the entire quantity and reversing the entire quantity are possible.
  • Currently , reversing the position is only allowed at market price. There should be an option to reverse the position at a limit price or stop loss price
  • Buying / Selling should be allowed from watchlist and position panels, without the necessity to load up the chart. A right click menu on these panels to initiate buying / selling would be very handy. Can be watching the chart of one instrument and initiate trading another instrument
  • Watch List should show the full name of the symbols. Every name is truncated after few characters and all symbol names, especially of options of different strikeprice looks same. There is no way to figure out the symbol without loading the respective charts. Time and data consuming and slow at many times
  • AMO orders never gets through. Always showing error. It looks like the AMO button is only show. No use at all
  • After market hours, almost always, the positions, orders and everything becomes blank. There is no way to research our positions or pending orders until the market hours of the next day
8 Likes

Hey @3AmvDrc97r,

Welcome to Fyers! :slight_smile:

  • Basket Order Feature is finally incorporated in Fyers Web. You can refer to our support article on how to place the same on our platform.
  • We’ll communicate this with the team and see if we can come up with it in the upcoming updates.
  • Reverse position is for quick action and immediate order placement. Hence it needs to be done at the Market. If you wish to reverse the position at a limit price or stop-loss price, then you can do it manually.
  • We’ll try to come up with it in the upcoming updates.
  • Your feedback is duly noted. We’ll communicate this with the team.
  • There is no issue in AMO as of now. Could you let us know the error? We’ll look into it.
  • Impossible! Kindly raise a ticket at [email protected] and we’ll get it checked ASAP.

Hope this helps!

1 Like

Hi Vanshika,

Thank you and appreciate you taking time to reply and address the issues. Thanks for your affirmative replies to take necessary steps to improve our trading experience. In this regard I would like to follow-up my original post with the following.

  • Yeah, Basket Orders seem to have been incorporated, thanks for that. But only if the combined margin requirement is shown in the basket order screen, it would be of any help. Looks like, It is just for the purpose of multiple orders at a go. Please show the combined margin for all the orders in the basket.
  • Partial exit from position panel, appreciate your affirmative reply Hope it will incorporated soon
  • When clicking the ‘Reverse Position’ or ‘Close Position’ button it brings up a confirmation dialogue box asking yes or cancel. Instead it would be better if it brings up the Buy/Sell window, where one can hit ‘Enter’ to confirm the default ‘entire’ quantity or alter the quantity if so desired. It wouldn’t be that difficult for your IT team to incorporate this.
  • Supposing I have a sell position of 4 lots. Seeing the market direction goes against my view, I would like to reverse, but not being sure of the reverse direction, I might prefer to only keep 2 lots in the reverse position and other 2lots closed. Same goes with closing the position, keep 2lots open and the other 2lots close. Just altering the quantity in the ‘Buy/Sell’ dialogue would easily achieve this. I think you people can do this.
  • Watch Lists should show the full name of the scripts to easily navigate. Even in two lines, it would be ok. Truncated names are really a drawback in quick fire trading scenarios.
  • . Regarding AMO orders, I have experienced multiple times, when trying to place AMO orders, especially in the morning before market opening, it most always brings up an error, saying ‘Error occurred, contact your stock broker’. I think AMO doesn’t only mean After Market, it also means ‘Before Market’ I guess. Evenings I don’t face this issue, but in the morning, the error always pops up.
  • Positions and Orders going blank, I am telling it seriously. I had an open Iron Condor position during last week end. The whole week end, I was only able to see one sell position, the other three disappeared. I was thinking, may be Fyers auto-squared off the other positions due to some margin issue or something. I was really confused and frustrated, was worried that what would happen to the open and seemingly naked sell position. I was doing all sorts of refreshing, clearing cache, restarting and all sort of things. Even in the mobile app, it was showing the same. Until 9:00 am on Monday, it was like that. Not showing the actual open positions. I decided to create new position to hedge the one open position visible. And all in a sudden all the other positions came on screen. This is not good. I wasn’t able to analyze my open position during the entire weekend. Even limit orders I placed on Friday disappeared during the entire weekend. It is ok, if for maintenance purposes, the site goes down for a certain period of time, but the whole weekend depriving us of our positions is really bad. Hope these kind of situations don’t arise in the future. If it occurs again, I will raise a ticket, but please make sure your team constantly quality check your platform and fix the bugs continuously.
  • Additionally, the notifications appearing on screen are too big and stays too long, cluttering the screen and blocking the chart. I disabled all notifications, but still the ‘Rejected Orders’ notifications repeatedly shows up every time I login during the day, or every refresh. It is unnecessary. One time showing the notifications is enough.
  • Problems in multiple tabs. Every time I duplicate a tab to follow another instrument, the new tab brings up the original watchlist and original chart that was opened on a particular day. Then we have to patiently navigate through the watchlists, select the instrument desired, and arrange the chart from scrap. If I duplicate a Crude Oil tab, it should bring up the Crude oil in the new tab, not ‘Bank Nifty’ which I was working in the morning. I have a watchlist for commodities, and I can easily choose another commodity, say Natural Gas easily. Small things, but these are all easily achievable for your IT team. Which will be a tremendous improvement in our trading experience with Fyers.
  • I have migrated from another broker to Fyers, for the intuitive trading platform and find it quite good. With some improvement I suggested above, it would be more user friendly and Fyers would become the best trading platform.

Thanks for your patience and

Best Regards

MS

And again, the glitches and bugs in Fyers web as well as mobile app seem never ending

  • Every now and then the web stops updating the chart, the price doesn’t move, no indication as to what is happening. Not even possible to refresh. Need to end process and restart the browser, by then miss out on buying or closing critical positions
  • In the mobile app, when I start the chart from Watchlist screen, it opens the first time correctly. Then go back and choose another script to open chart, it opens something else that we used earlier in the day. Always need to refresh the watchlist to open the correct chart for the selected instrument
  • It is getting more and more frustrating and disappointing to trade on these platforms
  • If these issues are not resolved in time, I am going to make a detailed video and post it to youtube to discourage anyone joining Fyers. I have incurred losses due to frequent crashes, glitches and bugs on these platforms. Very disappointing

MS

1 Like

Hi , I’m seeking this after 2 months, the points mentioned by @3AmvDrc97r totally valid and very badly impact on customer experience, I assume there must some of the issues already been resolved, unfortunately I’m experiencing same issue as of now, not only me perhaps there are many users experiencing same. If there any action plan/roadmap from FYERS can you please share with us.

1 Like

I cannot partially exit positions from fyers web. What a sad state of fyers web. Its high time i shift to other platforms.

I too am facing the issue of Missing open positions. I too opened an Iron Condor yesterday and today morning i am unable to view my open positions. It is really frustrating and not user friendly.

What about missing open positions ?? You have not answered it?? Really scary to trade in your platform.

1 Like