Back
2 Sep, 2024
6 mins read
For investors, the ultimate question is simple: How efficiently is a company using funds to generate returns? To answer this, investors rely on key financial metrics, with Return on Equity (ROE) and Return on Capital Employed (ROCE) standing out as vital indicators. Read on to know the meaning of these terms and the differences between ROE and ROCE.
Return on Equity, or ROE, is a financial metric that indicates how efficiently a company utilizes shareholders' money (equity) to generate profits. It measures the percentage return a company earns on its shareholders' equity (ownership).
It provides insights into profitability and management's effectiveness in using investor capital. ROE is a key indicator used to evaluate a company's financial health and performance in the share market.
ROCE, or Return on Capital Employed, is a financial metric used to assess how effectively a company is generating profits from the total capital it employs, which includes both debt and equity. It measures a company's return on the total capital invested.
A higher ROCE indicates that the company uses its capital more efficiently to generate profit. It's a crucial indicator for investors as it helps evaluate the profitability and efficiency of a company's core operations, making it easier to compare against industry standards or competitors.
ROE and ROCE provide insights into a company's financial performance and growth prospects. Here are the differences between them.
|
Parameters |
ROE (Return on Equity) |
ROCE (Return on Capital Employed) |
|---|---|---|
|
Definition |
ROE measures profitability from shareholders' equity alone. |
ROCE measures profitability from all capital sources (equity + debt). |
|
Focus |
This metric focuses on returns generated for equity shareholders. |
This metric focuses on returns generated from all capital providers. |
|
Scope |
ROE is restricted to considering only equity investors’ perspectives. |
ROCE considers a broader view, including equity and debt holders' interests. |
|
Purpose |
ROE helps investors assess the return on investment in the company's shares. |
ROCE helps investors evaluate how effectively the company uses all its capital to generate profit. |
|
Interpretation |
A higher ROE indicates better profitability relative to shareholders' equity. |
A higher ROCE indicates better efficiency in utilising all invested capital to generate profit |
|
Industry Comparison |
Useful for comparing companies relying on equity funding. |
ROCE helps compare companies that depend on both debt and equity funding |
After focusing on the meaning and key differences between ROE and ROCE, let's consider the formulas for calculating them.
1. ROE (Return on Equity) = Net Income / Shareholder’s Equity * 100
2. ROCE (Return on Capital Employed) = Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT) / Total Capital Employed * 100
Let us consider the following example to simplify the calculation and analysis of ROE and ROCE.
Consider Company Z Ltd.’s balance sheet with the following excerpt data.
|
Particulars |
2022-23 (Rs. in crores) |
2023-24 (Rs. in crores) |
|---|---|---|
|
Shareholder’s Equity |
50 |
60 |
|
Total Debt |
20 |
30 |
|
Total Assets |
70 |
90 |
|
Net Income |
10 |
15 |
|
Operating Profit / EBIT |
12 |
18 |
Formula to calculate ROE = Net Income / Shareholder’s Equity * 100
|
Year |
Calculation of ROE |
ROE |
|---|---|---|
|
2022-23 |
Net Income / Shareholder’s Equity * 100 = 10 / 50 * 100 |
20% |
|
2023-24 |
Net Income / Shareholder’s Equity * 100 = 15 / 60 * 100 |
25% |
1. Formula to calculate ROCE = EBIT / Capital Employed * 100
2. Formula to calculate Total Capital Employed = Total Equity + Debt Or Total Assets - Current Liabilities
|
Year |
Total Capital Employed |
Calculation of ROCE |
ROE |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2022-23 |
Total Equity + Debt = 20 + 50 = 70 |
EBIT / Capital Employed * 100 = 12 / 70 * 100 |
17.14% |
|
2023-24 |
Total Equity + Debt = 60 + 30 = 90 |
EBIT / Capital Employed * 100 = 18 / 90 * 100 |
20% |
ROE and ROCE are key parameters in assessing a company's financial performance. However, one ratio cannot be used in place of the other. Let’s understand the various scenarios in which you should use ROCE or ROE.
The various scenarios in which ROE can prove to be a tool for effective evaluation include -
Dividend Potential - ROE can indicate a company's ability to pay dividends. A higher ROE often means the company has more profits to distribute as dividends.
Growth Prospects - A strong ROE can signal that the company has good growth prospects, as it can generate substantial returns on the equity invested by shareholders.
Benchmarking Performance - ROE allows investors to benchmark a company's performance against industry averages. This helps in identifying the best-performing companies within a sector.
Identifying Market Leaders - Companies with consistently high ROE are often market leaders, as they can efficiently convert equity into profits compared to their peers.
Evaluating Strategic Decisions: ROE can be used to assess the impact of management’s strategic decisions on profitability, as effective management strategies typically result in higher ROE and vice versa.
Incentive Alignment: Management compensation is often tied to ROE, among other targets, ensuring that management’s interests are aligned with those of the shareholders.
Risk Assessment: ROE helps assess the risk of an investment. Companies with high ROE usually have strong business models and lower risk.
Portfolio Diversification: Investors can use ROE to select companies that enhance the diversification and return potential of their investment portfolio.
After considering the above cases, let us focus on the scenarios where ROCE can be an effective tool for evaluation and analysis.
Profitability Analysis: ROCE provides a clear picture of a company’s ability to generate profits from its total capital, making it an essential metric for comprehensive profitability analysis.
Resource Allocation: Efficient capital allocation is key to sustainable growth, and ROCE is instrumental in understanding how well a company allocates its resources to generate profits.
Capital Expenditure Evaluation: ROCE is particularly important for assessing the returns on significant capital expenditures, which are common in capital-intensive industries.
Debt vs. Equity Balance: ROCE takes into account both debt and equity, making it easier to compare companies with different capital structures and understand their true performance.
Cost of Capital: A comparison of ROCE to the company’s cost of capital helps investors determine if the company is generating sufficient returns to justify its capital structure.
Sustainable Growth: A consistently high ROCE indicates that a company can sustainably generate returns on its capital, which is crucial for long-term investment decisions.
Strategic Planning: ROCE helps in evaluating the long-term strategic plans of a company, ensuring that it can continue to generate returns above its cost of capital.
ROE (Return on Equity) and ROCE (Return on Capital Employed) are essential metrics for investors seeking to understand different aspects of a company's financial performance. Both metrics can allow investors a comprehensive understanding of a company's financial health and make informed investment decisions tailored to their investment goals and risk appetite.
ROE and ROCE serve different purposes, and therefore, no metric is better than the other. The choice between the two depends on the investor’s focus, and considering both metrics depends on their investment goals and the specific characteristics of the companies they are evaluating.
ROCE lower than ROE suggests that the company is generating higher returns relative to its equity compared to its total capital employed. This could indicate a higher reliance on debt, which affects the overall profitability when considering all capital sources.
You have successfully submitted your partnership request form. You will be hearing us soon!
